Josephine alibrandi and jacob coote relationship counseling

Novel Study Reflection | Year 10 English

josephine alibrandi and jacob coote relationship counseling

Characters: Josephine Alibrandi, Christina Alibrandi, Michael Andretti, Katia Themes: Cultural heritage, social classes/barriers, relationships, freedom, fulfilment, . How does Josie react to Jacob's advice,'Break away from those rules, Josie. Can you think of any advice that you would like to give to one of the characters? Alibrandi's relationship with Jacob Coote because I personally think, I would make Josie's parents come back together, Jacob Coote and. In Looking for Alibrandi, the author, Melina Marchetta demonstrates, the Relationships can be a catalyst for change; it can start show more content In the novel, John Barton dies; this death negatively influences the.

I also expected a twist in the novel but in the end, I am disappointed because everything ends perfectly. He is very protective and gradually supports his biological daughter as the story progresses. I admire his skills as a barrister when he protected Josie from being expelled. What character do you like least in this book?

The character I like the least in the book is definitely Jacob Coote because he does not follow certain rules. In other words, I do not like Jacob because he breaks the rule. At certain times, he is too ambitious-wanting everything to follow his way-and authoritative. Sometimes he purposely inflict pain on other people especially his loved ones. In general, I do not appreciate his behaviour and personality. The author creates suspense by creating cliff-hangers at the end of every chapter.

These cliff-hangers urge the readers to turn the page and see what will happen next. If I could change the ending of this book, I would twist the ending. I would make the ending more tragic, similar to Lord of the Flies by William Golding.

Remember ‘Looking for Alibrandi?’

I want the protagonist to realize her mistakes through loss, suffering, which will leave her as a scar in her age of adolescence. I want her to shift from a fragile position to a weaker position. The book definitely ended the way I thought it would because it is predictable for me as a reader. The author left hints along the way, which suggests that the protagonist is gradually changing, maturing and developing empathy for her peers and family.

Which character changed the most in this book? The protagonist changed the most in the novel. At the beginning, Josephine is very harsh on her heritage. At first, Josephine desperately wants to be part of Australian society but her peers do not accept for who she is.

She initially blames her heritage and her illegitimacy for causing this problem. Towards the end, she recognizes the importance of standing out instead of fitting in. She also gradually changes her perspectives about others and developing sympathy for them.

Did any characters make poor decisions? I believe that John Barton made the wrong decision by committing suicide. Although he was the handsome, popular and intelligent captain of St. However, I do not think that suicide is the only answer or way to escape the pressure. John had presented us his flaw and coward act through his death.

He had truly missed something that is worth living for. Who is the main character in this book? The protagonist of the novel is Josephine Alibrandi. Josephine is a typical teenager who has personal issues and hardships among her family. She has an Australian-Italian heritage. She is a growing teenager who is illegitimate and wanted to be emancipated.

She can be really rude and direct but deep down she is caring. She is not decisive and most of the time Josephine has trouble taking care of her own responsibilities. What character would you like to be in this book? Strange enough, I would like to be Poison Ivy or any unimportant characters because all of the main characters suffered a lot in their own ways. For example, Christina had to make sacrifices to bring Josie up. If I were an unimportant character like Poison Ivy, people would respect and look up to me.

Everyone in the school and community would accept me. What confused you in this book? There was no real connection between the chapters in which John Barton appeared to be happy and the chapters in which his death was presented. In my opinion, John Barton is a character who has a bright future and he chose to end it so suddenly. Apparently, John Barton has all of these traits so my family will be thrilled if I introduced him to them.

Describe the cover of your book. The cover of the novel consist of a teenage girl Josephine Alibrandi looking outside the window. The teenage girl gives a sign to the readers that the novel will focus on a particular teenage girl and her problems.

What is the main problem faced by characters in this book? The main problem faced by characters in this book is to be emancipated. They solved this problem through their gradual experience, which enabled them to strengthen their bond between their family and peers.

They begin to develop empathy for each other and realizes the importance of self-awareness. Did Christina and Michael rebuild their relationship? Did Josie and Jacob get back together? I disagreed with the fact that John Barton chose to end his life because he had no way out and because he just committed a coward action. I despise characters who do not have the guts to stand up for themselves. I also disagreed with the fact that Josie used swear words when she talked with her family because it shows her rudeness and her unappreciative character.

As the novel progresses, Josephine gradually shifts from a fragile position to a stronger position. This clearly shows that the process of change is evident in her adolescence years.

Can you think of any advice that you would like to give to one of the characters? If I could give advices to John Barton then I would encourage him not to suicide. Throughout the novel, I would encourage him with moving stories and touching quotes that would reduce the chance of John committing suicide. John needs to follow these advices because he can follow his own footsteps if he had more courage and strength to face his family.

He could really miss something that is worth living for. What is something that you hate about this novel? I dislike the use of inappropriate language in the novel. The ending was a bit too rushed and I think that the author could have done better. For example, the breakup between Josie and Jacob was so sudden. Although it is a twist and I loved that, the author did not describe any recent conflicts between the two lovers that led up to the break up. In other words, it happened in a blink of an eye.

What is something you really love about this novel? What I love about this novel is that teenagers can relate to it. I can relate my problems to hers. At a certain stage, this novel had helped me develop empathy towards my parents. What in this novel amused you or made you laugh? What in this novel made you cry? Nothing in the novel made me cry because I am often an insensitive person. It was a twist in the novel and John was one of my favourite characters in the book.

He seemed so perfect but in reality, he was a coward. What in this novel touched you deeply? Would you recommend this novel to a friend? Personally, I do not think that the novel has a high entertainment value so I do not recommend this book for entertainment and recreation.

However, this novel is very useful for analysing the gradual change that takes place in the age of adolescence. What did you learn about the study of English during this novel study? My vocabulary list expanded after reading the novel and I begin to understand the importance of captivating sentence structure. To be honest, I did not see any clues that help me to predict what was going to happen. Maybe I did not realise them. I think that we all have different traits and personalities that make up our own selves.

I think that it does. I know that the illegitimacy can be hardly criticised and there are not many people feel sympathetic to this problem. And we do have to be sympathetic so that everything can be at peace.

I would like to read other books by Melina Marchetta so that I can understand the ways how she sees things and solve them, and also her perspective. I can say that I like Josie mostly. I like them all the same.

A Visual Text Study of Looking for Alibrandi, directed by Kate Woods - WikiEducator

They all have their own reasons for their choices, and I think those are reasonable enough to make my sympathise them. The reason why this novel is so attractive to me is I really want to see how the characters would end up. I hoped that this would end in a happier way. Josephine Alibrandi, the main character changed the most in this book.

She was influenced by family relationships, friendships and altered her perspective and grow from a child to an adult.

Nonna Katia made a wrong decision of not fleeing away with Marcus Standford. She chose to stay back with fears and bad treatments from the husband. Josephine Alibrandi is the main character in this book. I just only confused with the family of John Barton. The father seems to be so authoritative.

Does he even understand the feeling of his own son? And I wonder how he felt when his son committed suicide. I would like to introduce Michael Andretti. This man is interesting and masculine. He firstly denied the fact that he had a daughter and had responsibility with her.

josephine alibrandi and jacob coote relationship counseling

That part of him was childish. Later on, he willingly to understand accepts her. The cover of the book describes a girl with curly hair sitting near the window, looking out the sky with a cup of coffee. Her eyes and facial expression show that she is thinking of something and that might be about her true identity and all the things that happened to her.

She is reflecting back of a year full of emotions and memories. They chose this particular cover because it described part of the main themes in the boolk. The main problems varied from different themes.

For family, they have to find the way to unite again and maintain the strong bind between each other. They solve the problem by forgiving and accepting the truth. I want to know if Jacob and Josie would be back together, because I like to see them being a couple.

And also if Josie passed the HSC exam or not. It would show how strong her mind was after knowing the death of John Barton and how intelligent she was. I disagree with the way how Nonna chose to criticise and face problems she had. It was just unfair for Christina. She should have chosen a different choice to live a better life. I really like the fact that Josie denies to sleep with Jacob.

She still keeps her manner and does not let it loose a bit. I would strongly recommend the Nonna to just free her mind a bit. And to Josephine, she should use polite and appropriate languages towards the elders. The use of languages and personalities of each character are unique.

Besides that, I love the complex she made for the plot. It makes the novel more interesting and not boring. That made she becomes special in my eyes. There was nothing that made me cry. I only felt sorry for some of them, especially the grandmother and John Barton. They lived in such an unfair world. The fact that John Barton felt completely pathetic and lonely in the heart. It was so deep and strong that led him to the stage of committing suicide.

They are also a way of showing how creative, imaginative and romantic Josie is. Carly is such a glamorous figure in her school that Josie believes there is some truth in this fantasy. The way that all of her friends fawn over her seem to Josie to be similar to this kind of movie star treatment. So hung up is Josie on the idea that she is going to marry into the world of John Barton, that she begins to dream about it. She becomes shadow attorney general like the most powerful lawyer in the country and all of the people she knows gather around her.

Josie's fear that this year is going to be disastrous is acted out in the fantasy that she is St. Barbara who was beheaded by her father. Coming shortly after meeting her father for the first time, clearly Josie is worried about how things will develop. Being rescued by Michael: After Michael talks their way out of being sued by Ron Bishop, the stained glass window in the stairwell at St.

Martha's changes to reveal Michael as an angel, rescuing Josie. Light builds behind it, making it almost a biblical miracle. After John Barton's death, the fantasy sequences get fewer and farther between. There are no more after Josie begins studying for her HSC. This represents something of a loss of innocence, where Josie is no longer as dreamy or as optimistic as she was at the beginning of the film. Important Events Josie meeting her father for the first time: This has a profound impact on Josie's life.

She goes through a range of emotions, but ends up seeing him as a person who has a lot to offer her, and who completes a part of her she never knew anything about.

He helps her with her studies and gives her practice working in a law firm. This helps Josie to see a number of things: This helps Josie to see the motives behind her grandmother's actions. She was trying to protect Christina, rather than punish her, and was hurt when she fell pregnant. By bringing everything out in the open, their feeling can begin to be resolved and they can move forward as three generations of strong, loving Alibrandi women.

Close Reading Tomato Day beginning The very first image of the film is an aeroplane flying somewhere. Josie desperately want to be somewhere else and the plane is one symbol of this. Tintorella di Luna and old Italian twist song plays in the background. This sequence is one continuous shot until Josie arrives. When she appears on camera, the colour returns to normal and editing begins.

It was shot on a handheld camera and coloured to make it look like an old home movie. This gets us thinking about a number of things: What reasons does Josie give for not wanting to be part of Tomato Day? Which important characters are introduced in this sequence? How does Josie show she doesn't want to be part of this world? What ideas does Josie express about her future? Martha's Josie walks up to her school while the wealthier students are dropped off in expensive cars. She tells us about her and her friends' circumstances, and says that fathers seem pretty useless anyway so why would she want one?

Carly Bishop is introduced and Josie runs through a fantasy scene where she is a famous model who is adored by the students at St. The colours that dominate this sequence are cold whites and blues making the school uninviting, very different to the warm reds and yellows of Josie's backyard.

josephine alibrandi and jacob coote relationship counseling

What contrasts are there between people like Carly Bishop and people like Josie Alibrandi in this scene? How has dialogue been used to introduce Carly's character? Meeting Michael for the first time Nonna's on the phone to one of her spy ring when Josie arrives. She's hot and irritable. When she tries to turn the air conditioning on, she's ushered out of the room because it's only for when guests are around.

Josie and Nonna argue and Nonna tells her to go home. Josie's just about to do this, when Michael's standing at the door. She's caught off guard and runs away, embarrassing Nonna. The soft focus and halo of light around Michael's face when the door is opened makes him seem angelic or like a star in a romantic film. One ironic line of dialogue is when Nonna says 'I was taught to speak English before you mother was born.

Why do you think Nonna like to speak Sicilian when Josie's around? Why does Michael say 'Christina's daughter?

Jacob drops Josie off Having just had an adrenaline-filled ride home, Jacob walks Josie up to her house. He tells her about her mother and the process he went through grieving for her. He thought she was wealthy because she goes to 'that snob school'. They pause and Jacob tries to kiss Josie, who initially pulls away, realises she's made a mistake and leans forward, by which time Jacob's pulled away. Why does Jacob seem interested in whether Josie would be at a school like Cook High if she wasn't on her scholarship?

What contrasts are there between Josie and Jacob? Setting John's soul free Lying in bed after the funeral, Josie remembers she has John's soul under her bed.

She gets it out and reads it. John wants to be all of the things people want him to be, but knows he can't be them all. All he wants is freedom. The camera mounted on a crane pulls back to allow John the freedom he desires. Tearing up the letter also tells the audience that she won't follow John towards suicide when things are difficult.

She won't hold on to the pain and the grief. What link is there between what John wants and Josie tearing up the letter? Why does John list the different things people want him to be? Breaking Carly's nose After breaking Carly's nose with her History book, Josie tries to handle it on her own, but after Carly criticises her for having no father, she brags about him being a solicitor.

She calls him and has to remind him where she goes to school. Michael arrives and tries to get Josie to tell him what name Carly called her, but she won't say. All she says is that nobody ever told John's friends they couldn't play at his house, bringing one of the underlying issues up. Michael understands and talks their way out of trouble.

What was the previous encounter between Josie and Michael? Why is there a pregnant pause after Michael says the words 'My daughter Why does Michael mention he has a bad temper?

Saying no Josie's concerned about what Sera said about her and Jacob's relationship being doomed because they're from different backgrounds. Jacob can see this instantly and tries to calm her down.

She meets his Dad and it is revealed that they have a close relationship. The kiss in Jacob's room and head towards having sex, but Josie decides she's not ready. Jacob gets anxious but Josie knows that just because Jacob and she have had different experiences with love and sex, they don't have to move at his pace. What might Jacob say in reply to Josie's comment that he lives without culture? What reasons does Jacob give for them being suited?

Why do you think things don't always run smoothly? Confronting Nonna Josie confronts Nonna about her hypocrisy. Nonna explains what is was like for her in a marriage where her husband was abusive. In her heart, she imagined she was married to Marcus Sandford back in Queensland.

She wanted to protect Christina from repeating the same fate and was upset when she found out that Christina had been seeing boys behind her back, and was pregnant. What things stop as a result of this scene? What does she learn about her Nonna as a result of this conversation?

Josie's first reaction is to run off and tell her mother. Why would that have been the wrong thing to do? Why was it better for them all to sit down and share it? Tomato Day end Tomato day again. A whole year has passed. This time Josie is much more secure in who she is, and accepts that her family is an important part of who she is. She doesn't try to run away as soon as she can, on the contrary, she brings first Jacob, then Sera and Anna in to help. The final clue that she is happy here is asking Nonna for a dance.

It symbolises the way they have resolved their differences. What has Josie achieved in the previous twelve months? Symbolism Travelling One of the most important symbols in the film is the idea of travelling. Josie's culture has been transported to Australia, and she is trying to transport herself to a different style of life. These are some of the more important examples of this symbol, or motif.

The very first shot of the film is of an aeroplane flying over the house.

Novel Study Reflection

Planes often symbolise people wanting to go places. The final sequence of the film also has a shot of an aeroplane, but this time, Josie simply looks up, happy exactly where she is.

Josie's first means of escape from her family at the beginning of the film is by travelling. She jumps in Sera's car and heads for the beach to escape 'National Wog Day'. John's expensive car is another reminder that they come from separate backgrounds. Carly is offered the lift, suggesting that she is more suitable for John because of her family. The cruel blow is that Josie initially thinks she is being offered a lift. Josie's relationship with Jacob is symbolised by the motorbike.

It is fast, unstable, dangerous but can also be a lot of fun. Driving over the bridge can also be seen to symbolise moving into adulthood because she considers having sex with him. Josie must take public transport to her school. She has to travel quite a distance because she can't afford to live in the wealthy area around the school. She also hopes that the scholarship will help her to travel to a 'better' life: The rollercoaster outside Michael's apartment could be seen as a symbol of Josie's life as a whole, but it particularly suits her relationship with her father.

It go through its ups and downs and certainly throws Josie around a bit. The Volcano The image of the volcano occurs a couple of times during the film, but it is quite an important symbol to remember when thinking of Josie. Lots of things are building up inside her and they often come out in shows of strong emotion.

She often deals with problems by yelling, abusing someone or crying, all of which can be seen to be similar to a volcano welling up and overflowing. The first example of the volcano occurs when Jacob offers to give Josie a lift home. Behind them as they are getting onto the bike, a screen is playing footage of a volcano exploding. Josie's emotions are also welling up in this scene, with her frustration at not being asked to dance by John Barton being matched against her rising interest in Jacob.

josephine alibrandi and jacob coote relationship counseling

The second instance of the volcano symbol is on the glass wall of the Bar Stromboli where Josie has coffee with her father.

Things are welling up inside her over her relationship with her father too, particularly given that Nonna doesn't like her seeing him. Throughout the film, Josie's emotions swing from not wanting anything to do with her father, to wanting he and her mother to get back together.

Occasionally it gets too much for her and she erupts at him. Hands Hands are often things that we take for granted, but watching what they do in a film can be quite a useful way of exploring ideas and relationships. In both of the Tomato Day sequences, hands dominate the shots. Most of the people present are doing something with their hands, largely towards making the pasta sauce for the family. Because of this, they symbolise the way that people can do things for others.

Other examples include preparing meals for other people Nonna does this often to show you care for them and you want them to be happy and well. When Josie leaves to go to Bondi with her friends, she washes her hands of tomato juice.

This is symbolic of what she wants to do with her family and culture as a whole at the beginning of the film: She learns that it isn't as easy as that, and by the end of the film, she has learnt that she is better off embracing them, rather than being ashamed of them. When Nonna is angry at Josie's cheekiness, she raises her hand as if to discipline her, but drops it when her point is made. Hands can communicate peoples' emotions, and especially show when they are angry. Another time hands reveal emotions is when Josie uses her to break Carly's nose with a history book.

Soundtrack When studying film, the word soundtrack measn everything you can hear, not just the music used in the film. Having said that, the background music used in the film is quite significant. Background Music The producers of the film wanted the music to be an important part of the film.

The lyrics of most of the songs used in the film enhance the audience's understanding of what occurs during each scene. Here are a few examples. I can't live, with or without you Nothing to win and nothing left to lose Your kiss is as wicked as an M and you talk like a volcano and you're everything to me. They help her through difficult times and they help her to understand things. When Josie introduces us to her friends, she says that they 'kinda happened by default', but despite this, they are excellent friends who help each other out enormously.

Coming from similar backgrounds as Josie, she feels as though she's not alone at St. John's death helps Josie to see a number of things: When John dies, Anna and Sera wait by the lockers so they can be around when Josie gets to school. They try to break it to her as gently as possible and tidy up Josie's dropped things after she runs out. They leave her to go too, understanding she needs space. Sera's comment that you need to be from the same background to make a relationship work might be based in the truth, but it's not as simple as that.

Josie learns that it might be true, but it might not be as well. The reassurance she seeks from Jacob is quickly given.

The pressure to be perfect Lots of the images that only appear on the screen for a second, or might appear in the background are very important in the story. All of the posters and magazine covers below were made by the Art Department working on the film and laced in important places. This sign is on the back of the bus as Josie enters St. It has women admiring themselves on it, but also the phrase 'Eastwest'. Josie is trying to get from the poorer Western suburbs of Sydney to the richer Eastern suburbs.

The Skamp magazine appears twice before Josie is called out in front of class. This shows how much image and magazines like this are revered at St. Notice one of the articles is called 'Claws to die for', which makes the girls seem like animals who are capable of killing each other.